25 July 2009       Attendance: 395

Buxton won 4-3 on penalties.

Team: Scott Hartley, Indy Aujla, Tommy Agus, Sam Liversidge, Gregg Anderson, Neil Stevens, Kieran Lugsden, Michael Towey, Jon Froggatt, Gavin Knight, Steve Ridley
Subs: Paul Walker, Danny Reet, Kyle Collins, Grant Balck, Scott Maxfield
Goalscorers: